Sherry was last seen at approximately 8pm, the evening of August 29, 1991. According to her live-in boyfriend, Sherry asked him for some money to go shopping. That evening family members found Sherry's car in the parking lot of a Target store in Paradise Valley, AZ. Though Sherry is very petite, it was noted that the driver's seat of her vehicle had been pushed back, enough for an individual over 6'0" tall. Her identification and purse were later found at her home. Witnesses stated they saw her alive two days before she was reported missing. Foul play is suspected in Sherry's disappearance.