Facebook Pixel

Melissa Witt

A 19 year old college student disappears in a parking lot

  • Last updated: December 4, 2023
  • Fort Smith, AR
  • December 1, 1994

Overview of Melissa Witt

2023 Update

In honor of the 29th anniversary of Melissa's disappearance, the Who Killed Melissa Witt Investigative Team is now offering a $29,000 reward. The reward is being offered for any leads to Melissa Witt's Mickey Mouse watch and the arrest and conviction of the person responsible for her kidnapping and murder. Or any information that can help identify two witnesses who were at Bowling World that night.

1. A short male with a mustache, and glasses, who was allegedly wearing a blue shirt, jeans, brown boots, and a white or light-colored baseball cap on the day of the kidnapping. Officials say the man was seen standing outside of Bowling World on the sidewalk smoking that day. Officials say it is likely that this man "heard and/or saw the very loud alteration" between Melissa and her abductor.
2. A couple with a young child who was at the time between 8 to 10 years of age. These people were allegedly seen "walking across the parking lot and going into Bowling World that day," the release says. The woman is described as short, blonde, with "fluffy" hair. She was also said to have been wearing a "tan/light colored" striped sweater. The man she was with was described as taller than the woman.

Could a digital billboard campaign help find Missy Witt’s murderer nearly 30 years later?

Source: 5newsonline

Melissa Witt was a hardworking and ambitious, 19-year-old college student. Also known as Missy, she was an honors student at Westark Community College in Fort Smith, Arkansas where she lived with her mother, Mary Ann. Missy kept very busy with classes and her part-time job at a local dental clinic where she worked as a dental assistant. Her friends say she was friendly, kind-hearted, and a hard worker, which would serve her well as she dreamed of and was working toward her goal of becoming a dental hygienist.

The day Missy went missing

December 1, 1994, was a typical day for Missy. But as she got ready to go to campus for class, she had a small disagreement with her Mom after asking her if she could borrow money. Her mother said no and before she left the house, she left Missy a note explaining that she loved her and that she would be at a local bowling alley later that afternoon if she wanted to come by and get something to eat.

Between 6:30-7 pm, after class and work, Missy went to the same bowling alley that her mother had mentioned in her note. She parked her car, and before she would even make it inside the bowling alley, investigators believe Missy was abducted from the parking lot. They made this determination based on evidence of a struggle around her car, including blood found in the parking lot, as well as Missy's keys and an earring found nearby.

Source: 5NEWS

When she was discovered

Six weeks after the abduction, two hunters in the Ozark National Forest discovered Missy's body on January 13, 1995—45 miles from her home in Fort Smith. Missy's body was nude and placed near a headstone-shaped rock. However, Missy's clothes and personal belongings were missing from the scene and were never found.

Source: Who Killed Missy Witt?

Larry Swearingen was looked at as a person of interest in this case. He was convicted of the murder of Melissa Trotter who was killed in a very similar manner as Missy. Both girls were 19 at the time of their death, and both were murdered and found in large forests in Arkansas. Furthermore, Swearingen was known to be in the area around the time Missy was abducted. Swearingen denied murdering Missy Witt and was executed on January 27, 2009, for Melissa Trotter's murder.

Source: Who killed Missy Witt?

Where the case stands today

No one has been convicted of her murder, and there is currently a $5,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction of the individual responsible for Missy's abduction and murder.

A documentary is being developed to cover Missy's case, and community advocates recently launched a billboard campaign to highlight her unsolved murder.

Source: Who Killed Missy Witt?

Anyone with information on the individuals described is asked to call 1-800-440-1922 or email whokilledmissywitt@gmail.com.


  1. Date Missing:December 1, 1994
  2. Date Found:January 13, 1995
  3. Birthday:April 20, 1975
  4. Age at Incident:19
  5. Race:Caucasian / White
  6. Gender:Female


What's Left to be Uncovered

Featured Sources

Important People


Tap to Activate the Map


Online Resources (6)

Podcasts (15)

Misc (52)

More Cases to Explore

There are currently no cases that match the selected filters.