Facebook Pixel

Peggy Sweeten

Do you know what happened to Peggy?

  • Last updated: April 19, 2023
  • Grove, OK
  • January 17, 1998

Overview of Peggy Sweeten

Could a recent discovery at Grand Lake in Oklahoma help solve a 25-year-old cold case?

Authorities believe that a rusted-out 55-gallon drum, located at the bottom of a cove, may contain important clues to the disappearance of Peggy A. Sweeten went missing on January 13, 1998. Peggy, who was 52 years old at the time of her disappearance, lived with her husband, James Lee Sweeten, in a lakefront home at Four Seasons Resort on Grand Lake. None of her personal belongings, including her car, clothing, photos or mementos, were missing from the property.

According to a search warrant filed in 2011, Peggy's son, Patrick Sweeten, told investigators that he learned his mother was missing in March 1998 and had to force his father to file a missing person's report in June 1998. James Sweeten reportedly told authorities that his wife had left with a man she had met online. However, this statement has been called into question as Peggy Sweeten did not use email and never had an email address.

Patrick Sweeten also reported noticing a 55-gallon drum on his parents' property that was suddenly missing. When he questioned his father, James Sweeten, about the barrel, the elder Sweeten shrugged his shoulders and said he didn't know anything about it, according to Mark Wall, a Delaware and Ottawa County Cold Case detective.


  1. Date Missing:January 17, 1998
  2. Age at Incident:51
  3. NAMUS Number:MP8981
  4. Race:White / Caucasian
  5. Gender:Female
  6. Height:5'2"
  7. Weight:145 lbs
  8. Hair Color:Black
This case needs attention

Our goal is to crowdsource the more than 200,000 unsolved cases of the murdered and missing. Help us add more information to this case. Click here to join us


Misc (2)

More Cases to Explore

There are currently no cases that match the selected filters.