Andrews left her nursing job at the Methodist Manor in Seaford, Delaware around 23:15 on November 16, 1990. About 2:00PM the next day, her 1985 Mercury Cougar was discovered abandoned behind a business on U.S. 13 north of Seaford. Andrews' purse and belongings were scattered on the ground near the driver's side door, and her keys were on the trunk lid. She was never seen again. Foul play is suspected. Andrews, a mother of two grown daughters, had divorced in 1982 but was reconciling with her ex-husband.