Dave (pictured above) was looking to try online dating to meet someone for a casual relationship. To his luck, he met Liz and Cari — both single moms with winning personalities that helped Dave come out of his shell.

But when one romance soured, it turned Dave’s life into a twisted love triangle, putting him and everyone he loved at risk.

This newest Netflix documentary uses interviews with those involved, including the detectives who cracked the case, alongside vivid reenactments to bring viewers into the tension and paranoia of Dave’s 4-year nightmare.

♥️Love these binge-worthy content recommendations? Get them — and much more — in your inbox.

Uncovered’s bi-weekly true crime newsletter, 🔎The Citizen Detective, includes links to criminally good content in every edition. Click here to sign up for our run-downs of what’s happening in the true crime world, cold cases, trending mysteries, and trial updates — so you don’t have to do the digging.